October Decline in U.S. Commercial Insurance Renewal Rates
October sees a decline in U.S. commercial insurance renewal rates, with commercial property as an exception.
The U.S. commercial insurance market experienced notable shifts in October, according to the Ivans Index, a respected benchmark for premium renewal rates. While most major lines witnessed a reduction in premium renewal rate increases, commercial property emerged as a notable outlier with its rates rising slightly. The data highlights year-over-year increases in most lines, including commercial auto, business owner's policy (BOP), general liability, commercial property, and umbrella insurance, with only workers' compensation showing a decrease.
Renewal Rate Trends
In October, the average renewal rate changes were led by umbrella insurance at an increase of 6.08%, with commercial property following closely at 5.37%, and BOP at 5.21%. A closer examination of month-over-month data reveals a decrease in renewal rates across most lines, including commercial auto, BOP, general liability, umbrella, and workers’ compensation. Notably, commercial property diverged from this pattern: it was the only major insurance line to see its renewal rates rise over the previous month.
Quarterly Market Dynamics
The data from Ivans also sheds light on broader quarterly trends. The third quarter showed a general deceleration in renewal rate increases across most insurance lines, except for workers’ compensation. The most pronounced slowdown was observed in general liability, which dropped to a 4.12% increase from 5.44% in the second quarter. This trend of deceleration mirrors the overall decrease in the pace of premium rate increases throughout the year. For instance, renewal rates for commercial auto dropped from an average of 5.28% in the first quarter to 3.63% by the third.
Industry Implications and Expert Insights
According to Michael Streit, president of Applied Carrier, the market is currently softening, prompting agencies and brokers to consolidate business with preferred carrier partners. This strategic focus is likely an adaptive maneuver in response to changing renewal rate trends and competitive market pressures. Meanwhile, an independent forecast by the Insurance Information Institute and Milliman indicates that net combined ratios for general liability and commercial auto may remain above 100 this year, underscoring ongoing claims cost pressures.
Understanding the Ivans Index
The Ivans Index stands as a critical barometer for gauging premium renewal trends, drawing from a vast pool of over 120 million data transactions across 38,000 agencies and 700 carriers and MGAs. By leveraging such comprehensive data, the Index provides a detailed snapshot of the U.S. insurance market, offering valuable insights into the dynamics of premium rate changes. For insurance professionals seeking strategic insights and market intelligence, these trends are readily accessible via Market Insights, with the recent Q3 2026 report available for download.