Mid-Year Update on Auto Insurance Claims in 2026

Auto insurance claims have continued to show a decline in 2026, although the decrease is not as pronounced as seen in the previous year, according to the CCC Intelligent Solutions’ Crash Course 2026 Mid-Year Update.

The report reveals important trends in the auto insurance industry, with total loss frequency becoming a significant factor due to elements such as higher deductibles, aging vehicles, and increasingly complex repair needs. From January to September, claims frequency dropped by 3.5%, a trend that is starkly different from the 8.3% reduction witnessed during the same period in 2025. Repairable claims have decreased by 5.4%, but the valuations for total losses saw an uptick of 1.1%, reflecting a shift in the types of claims being processed.

Market Shifts and Repair Costs

The landscape of auto repairs is evolving with comprehensive claims experiencing a nearly 10% decline, a change driven partially by reduced vehicle thefts and lower catastrophic claim occurrences. Vehicle repair costs have also risen slightly, with the average cost reaching $4,821 in the first half of the year, marking a modest 0.6% increase, though these costs remain over 40% higher than those recorded in 2020. Part prices escalated by approximately 8% year-over-year, while labor rates saw a smaller 1.5% hike. However, the demand for repair parts and labor hours has dropped from previous highs, providing some respite.

Adding a layer of complexity to future market dynamics, the report notes the introduction of impending 50% tariffs on Canadian automobiles and auto parts, scheduled for January 1, 2027. This policy could have far-reaching implications for cost structures within the U.S. auto repair and insurance sectors.

Trends and Consumer Behavior

An interesting consumer behavior outlined in the study is the noticeable increase in high-deductible policies. Specifically, 28.4% of repairable collision claims involve deductibles of $1,000 or more, rising from 25.7% in the prior year. Total loss frequency has risen to 23.5% across all loss categories by the second quarter, with older vehicles predominantly contributing to these statistics. Vehicles aged seven years or more accounted for a notable 74.3% of total loss valuations.

Age of Vehicle Percentage of Total Loss
7+ years 74.3%
6 years or newer 56% of self-pay repairs

The report from CCC highlights a trend where a noteworthy 40.4% of policyholders with confirmed total losses switched insurance carriers, while only 7.6% did the same after repairable claims. This shift indicates an increasing consumer demand for flexibility and affordability in insurance offerings. Furthermore, there's a rising preference for direct payments rather than making insurance claims, with self-pay repairs making up 26% of repair orders, averaging $1,941. A significant proportion of these repairs, over 71%, were under $2,000, contrasting with approximately 75% of repairable insurance claims exceeding this cost mark.

Technological Influence and Future Outlook

Technology's role in claim processes is expanding, with diagnostic procedures becoming more common. In the first quarter, 74.8% of repairable appraisals included scanning, up from 70.9% the previous year, and calibrations increased to 29.9% from 23.3%. This advancement emphasizes the importance of up-to-date diagnostics in managing repair costs effectively.

As hybrid and electric vehicles gain prominence, their impact on claims is palpable. Hybrids accounted for 9.9% of repairable claims in the second quarter, compared to electric vehicles at 4.3%. Repair costs for new hybrids are at $6,415 and $6,850 for electric vehicles. Since 2020, such costs have increased significantly by 53.6% for hybrids and 16.3% for electric vehicles, reinforcing the need for carriers to consider these upward trends in their strategies and pricing models.