Florida Court Overturns $700K Medical Award: Implications for Insurers

A Florida appeals court has overturned a significant jury award of $700,000 in medical expenses related to a child's car accident injuries, setting the new total at approximately $134,000. The case features Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company and a defendant driver.

The Fourth District Court of Appeal ruled that the initial trial should have adjusted the compensation based on the evidence provided, which did not justify the entire awarded amount. Notably, the court preserved the child's opportunity to file a potential bad faith claim against Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company, highlighting an important aspect for claims professionals in similar cases.

Details of the Incident and Initial Trial

The accident leading to this legal case occurred in February 2018, involving a child passenger in her father’s vehicle. A later crash in the same year was resolved separately, narrowing the trial to the original event. During the trial, evidence included a physician’s testimony that aggressive treatment was not necessary after July 2018. However, a neurosurgeon suggested future spinal surgery might be needed, projecting the hospital and procedure costs.

Medical expenses incurred in the past were tallied at $47,573.88, with future expenses envisaged at $106,500. The total compensation requested also included damages for pain and suffering anticipated over the child's lifetime, totaling $1,834,073.88. The jury allocated 30% of the fault to the defendant driver and 70% to the child’s father, ultimately awarding $700,000 for medical costs and an additional $10,000 for pain and suffering.

The Appeals Court's Analysis and Decision

The appeals court concluded that the medical expenses awarded were unsupported by evidence, emphasizing that Florida law necessitates future medical costs to be "reasonably certain." As presented, the evidence substantiated $47,573.88 in past medical expenses and about $86,000 for potential future surgical procedures.

Consequently, the case is headed back to the trial court for award recalibration. The child's legal team might contest the revised award, potentially prompting a retrial focused exclusively on medical expenses.

Implications for Insurance Professionals

The initial judgment retains the child's ability to advance a bad faith claim against Allstate for the original amount, despite the policy limit of $25,000. This aspect underlines that while physical injuries may influence claims, procedural diligence remains critical in determining damages. This case elucidates for insurers the heightened proof needed for future medical expenses claims, especially under low-limit auto policies.

  • Original medical expenses claim: $700,000
  • Revised medical expenses: ~$134,000
  • Policy limit involved: $25,000
  • Potential for bad faith claim: Preserved

This landmark decision reinforces the importance of comprehensive evidence when substantiating medical claims and clarifies ongoing risks associated with bad faith claims even after verdict recalibration. Insurance professionals should monitor developments as the ruling is still open to rehearing motions.