Navigating Changes in the Excess & Surplus Insurance Market
The Excess & Surplus (E&S) insurance market is navigating significant shifts, as revealed in a recent roundtable discussion hosted by Insurance Business TV with leaders from Amwins, AJ Wayne & Associates, and E-Risk.
The discussion revealed that new capacity, wholesale broker consolidation, and changes in underwriting practices are reshaping the E&S landscape. Andrew Kelly from AJ Wayne & Associates highlighted a trend where investor-driven goals influence underwriting appetite, creating increased competition and rate pressure. Liz Goldie of Amwins emphasized distinguishing genuine underwriting appetite from capital-driven growth, while James Walsh of E-Risk stressed the need for sustainable growth strategies for new market entrants.
Key Factors for Success in a Changing Market
The growth of program business and Managing General Agents (MGAs) using E&S paper are pivotal trends. Goldie advised retail brokers to conduct thorough due diligence, focusing on factors such as carrier stability, claims handling, and reinsurance backing. For MGAs, Walsh cited the importance of solid underwriting talent, innovative distribution, and technological efficiency.
Broker Consolidation and its Implications
Broker consolidation continues to impact the E&S market. Walsh noted that as large retail firms build internal networks, they may alter service levels and diminish options for insureds. Kelly added that these changes challenge current wholesale relationships, underlining the importance for independent brokers to maintain expertise and specialization to provide optimal client outcomes.
Underwriting Shifts and Market Dynamics
Changes in underwriting, especially in casualty risk, are notable. Kelly observed an increased use of exclusions and changes in policy language, while Goldie highlighted stricter underwriting disciplines in areas like excess liability. Both agreed that maintaining firm underwriting principles is key to countering issues induced by social inflation.
Indicators of Market Softening
The panel discussed potential signs of market softening, with Walsh citing lower prices and broader coverage in professional liability and cyber insurance as indicators. Kelly warned against unsustainable rates, advocating for realistic underwriting to ensure long-term market stability. According to Goldie, ongoing rate reductions coupled with unresolved loss trends necessitate proactive policy evaluations.
| Key Issues | Implications |
|---|---|
| Investor Goals | Influence underwriting appetite, increasing competition |
| Broker Consolidation | Changes service levels and options for insureds |
| Rising Exclusions | Added scrutiny in policy underwriting |
Overall, the roundtable highlighted the evolving nature of the E&S market, with strategic differentiation, disciplined growth, and comprehensive partnership evaluations being crucial for navigating current and future changes.