ACE Takes Legal Action Against eBay Over $55.7M Harassment Settlement
ACE Property & Casualty Insurance Company is taking legal action against eBay and several of its former executives to dispute liability for a $55.7 million settlement linked to harassment claims from publishers Ina and David Steiner of EcommerceBytes.
The insurer's fight, which began with a case filed on November 12 in the Northern District of California, names former eBay CEO Devin Wenig, ex-Chief Communications Officer Steve Wymer, and former Senior VP Wendy Jones as defendants. ACE argues that eBay's activities, under the auspices of their security team, amounted to purposeful behavior not covered under their insurance policy. Furthermore, ACE is accusing the defendants of breach of contract for pushing forward with the settlement negotiations without duly informing the insurer.
Insurance Policy Disputes
The dispute traces back to November 2022 when ACE first contested whether its umbrella liability coverage should extend to losses derived from criminal or deliberate acts. This initial litigation was dismissed in May 2023, pending the outcome of the Steiners' allegations. Reviving these issues, the updated lawsuit also includes accusations about the defendants' behavior during settlement discussions earlier this year.
ACE asserts that eBay reached out about the Steiners' lawsuit, seeking indemnity under a $50 million policy without sharing essential information for proper evaluation. The insurer claims eBay entered settlement talks without their sufficient involvement and requested consent or a waiver of obligations in 2026, lacking critical details necessary at the deal's time of agreement.
Implications of Settlement Terms
Challenges in cementing the agreement led to the case reopening in June and resulted in a finalized accord in July. The insurance company stresses that it did not review or approve this agreement before its finalization. ACE is pursuing damages and exclusion from any obligation to cover costs relating to the settlement.
Complications arise regarding payment allocations, with ACE questioning if the compensations reflect emotional distress or categories like bodily injury, impacting coverage eligibility. Coverage for the $7 million earmarked for charitable contributions within the settlement remains another contested point.
Legal and Regulatory Context
A related legal verdict in August 2025 allowed claims of both negligence and intentional misconduct against eBay and its former executives, reinforcing ACE's position under California Insurance Code Section 533 against covering willful acts. Evidence in court files reveals involvement from eBay executives in orchestrating activities against the Steiners, including directives to target the publishers. This led to criminal charges against multiple former employees, alongside eBay's acceptance of responsibility under a deferred prosecution agreement in January 2024 following government charges.
| Entity | Settlement Allocation |
|---|---|
| Steiners Compensation | $48.7 million |
| Charitable Contributions | $7 million |
The case remains live in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, with defendants awaiting responses to the new complaint. For insurance professionals, this case underscores the complexities of coverage interpretation, particularly in instances involving potential willful misconduct and the intricacies surrounding settlement discussions and policy scopes. It serves as a pertinent reminder of the importance of clear communication and full transparency between insured parties and their insurers to manage risks effectively and avoid potential litigation.