Impact of Litigation Costs on Insurance in Texas and Kentucky

The Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) has launched a campaign to spotlight the impact of attorney advertising and third-party litigation funding in Texas and Kentucky, in light of escalating litigation costs affecting insurance premiums.

The initiative, "Life of a Billboard Attorney," features a trio of 30-second streaming videos aimed at coinciding with the 2027 legislative sessions in these states. It emerges amid mounting concerns over litigation expenses, with a recent analysis by Triple-I and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Institute for Legal Reform revealing that U.S. tort costs skyrocketed to $579.7 billion in 2023, a substantial increase from $299.7 billion in 2014. These figures echo the findings of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), indicating a significant upward trajectory in legal expenses.

Impact on Insurance Rates

The rise in litigation costs has a pronounced effect on casualty insurance rates, particularly influencing casualty sectors like umbrella and excess liability. As WTW’s Commercial Lines Insurance Pricing Survey reports, while some property insurance rates have seen declines, casualty insurance continues to experience significant rate hikes. This split in rate trends underscores the influence of increased litigation exposure on casualty products.

The primary drivers behind these tort costs are other liabilities, totaling $249.3 billion, and personal auto liability at $188.1 billion. The high costs in these categories illuminate the broader effects on casualty insurance pricing strategies, necessitating diligent risk assessment and pricing adjustments by insurance carriers.

Legislative Landscape and Campaign Strategy

Texas and Kentucky are prominent in this campaign for their legislative dynamics concerning litigation funding. Texas is progressing toward adopting litigation funding transparency rules, a shift that gained momentum after the state's Supreme Court opened public commentary on these regulations. Meanwhile, Kentucky remains among the minority of states without disclosure requirements, as highlighted by a Triple-I report on litigation funding reform.

The introduction of third-party litigation funding (TPLF) has catalyzed debates about its role in the legal system. While some argue TPLF enhances accessibility to justice, critics point to it as a significant contributor to the escalation of liability insurance losses. An estimated $231.6 to $281.2 billion has been added to such losses over the past decade, attributed to legal system abuses.

Strategic Implications for Insurance Professionals

This new campaign enhances awareness of the ripple effects litigation costs have on the insurance industry, from claims to premiums. Insurance professionals, including underwriters and carriers, should closely monitor these developments. The current patchwork of state laws regarding TPLF significantly influences how underwriters evaluate exposure, directly affecting carrier strategies and policy pricing.

“Litigation is outgrowing the economy,” stated Michel Léonard, chief economist and data scientist at Triple-I. “That gap doesn’t stay in the courtroom. It lands in claims, reserves, and premiums.”
Michel Léonard, Triple-I

Key Categories Driving Tort Costs

Category Cost in Billions Impact
Other Liability $249.3 Drives high casualty rates
Personal Auto Liability $188.1 Influences auto insurance pricing

As legislative measures evolve, insurance industry stakeholders must remain vigilant in adapting to policy changes and their corresponding impacts on underwriting and claims management. Such awareness and strategic adaptation will be crucial for navigating the turbulent waters of a legally dynamic landscape.