King Risk Partners Acquires Lott & Gaylor Insurance in Florida
King Risk Partners has announced the acquisition of Lott & Gaylor Insurance, a Fort Myers-based agency, marking a strategic expansion in Florida despite many competitors slowing similar activities.
This acquisition underscores King Risk's commitment to enhancing its offerings in personal, commercial, and specialty lines across Southwest Florida. Scott Popilek, CEO of King Risk Partners, cited Lott & Gaylor's established relationships and deep understanding of regional insurance needs as essential assets that will strengthen King Risk's market position. Furthermore, David Maxwell, President of Lott & Gaylor, emphasized the importance of aligning with a partner like King Risk, who shares their commitment to client relationships and service quality.
Strategic Expansion Amid Florida's Changing Landscape
King Risk Partners, ranked as the 36th largest insurance brokerage in the U.S., has been proactive in leveraging its affiliations with private equity firms Lightyear Capital and BHMS Investments. Following a successful recapitalization in April 2025, the firm embarked on an ambitious acquisition spree, incorporating 14 agencies that year alone. The Lott & Gaylor acquisition follows other strategic moves, including the addition of professional liability specialists and leadership positions in 2026.
Florida's insurance market has become increasingly attractive due to recent legislative reforms in 2022 and 2023. These developments have stabilized the environment, drawing in new property insurers and stimulating competition, thus making Florida-based agencies enticing acquisition prospects.
Florida's M&A Market: Opportunities and Challenges
Although the overall insurance sector has seen a decline in mergers and acquisitions, with transaction volumes reaching an eight-year low by the third quarter of 2026, King Risk Partners continues its selective expansion. The firm’s moves are part of a broader trend where private equity-backed buyers focus on high-value, well-managed agencies. Tim Cunningham of OPTIS Partners noted that while valuations remain strong for larger firms, the acquirer pool has become more discerning. King Risk’s actions reflect private equity’s belief in Florida's growth potential and the strategic value of this acquisition.