Court Rules Against S. Brown & Associates in Text Message Case

The Central District of California has ruled against S. Brown & Associates (SBA) in their motion to dismiss a lawsuit that alleges the unlawful sending of text messages to a phone number on the National Do Not Call Registry. This case, Miller v. S. Brown & Associates, Inc., highlights the legal complexities surrounding text message communication in the insurance industry.

The plaintiff in the case received text messages in November 2025, informing her about the expiration of her temporary auto insurance with National General Insurance Company (NGIC) and suggesting savings with Direct Auto Insurance. These messages came under scrutiny due to her phone number's registration on the National Do Not Call (DNC) Registry. SBA, which serves as a program administrator for NGIC, collected customer data, but the plaintiff claimed she never consented to receive such messages.

Legal Considerations in the Case

Initially, the lawsuit targeted Direct General Insurance Agency. However, the court dismissed this claim due to a lack of sufficient evidence for liability. Focus then shifted to SBA after new evidence implicated them as the message senders. SBA's defense referenced the Seventh Circuit's interpretation in Steidinger v. Blackstone Medical Services, arguing that text messages should not be considered under the same liability as calls. However, the court adhered to the Ninth Circuit's view, treating text messages as calls under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), allowing the case to move forward.

Implications for Insurance Administrators

The case emphasizes the importance for insurance administrators in understanding and adhering to communication regulations, particularly those governing customer data and marketing messaging. The specificity of the text messages, as connected to SBA and dealership records, provided a basis for the court to recognize the potential for direct liability.

Key Takeaways for Industry Professionals

  • Ensure strict compliance with consumer communication regulations, including the TCPA, to avoid liability.
  • Verify that all marketing communications have explicit consumer consent.
  • Maintain clear records and understanding of any established business relationships.

The Road Ahead

This case is a cautionary tale for insurance entities managing consumer information. It serves as a reminder of the potential legal repercussions when consumer communication strategies do not align with regulatory standards. As litigation progresses, insurance administrators should carefully monitor the outcomes to better navigate the nuanced legal landscape of direct consumer interactions, especially in regions where text messages are classified as calls under TCPA.