Customer Trust Declines Among Life Insurance Providers: JD Power Study

In 2026, customer trust in U.S. life insurance providers saw a decline, particularly among Generation Z and financially vulnerable groups, as revealed by the JD Power Individual Life Insurance Study.

The study highlights a critical shift in the life insurance industry as providers transition from transactional relationships to more engaging, ongoing interactions with policyholders. While overall customer satisfaction remained relatively stable, trust satisfaction experienced a more significant decline, dropping by 9 points. This downturn signals challenges for insurers in nurturing long-term customer loyalty, especially as digital communication becomes integral to service delivery.

Engagement and Trust Challenges

Meaghan Hafner, JD Power's senior director of health & life solutions, emphasizes the evolving nature of life insurance from a one-time purchase to a continuous engagement model. Insurers are striving to enhance digital channels and maintain frequent communication, yet building lasting customer connections remains elusive for some. According to the study, customers reporting seamless multi-channel interactions showed high levels of satisfaction, trust, and advocacy. However, disruptions in service, like difficulties in reaching a representative or unexpected fees, could lead to a significant drop in trust.

Gen Z and Credit-Vulnerable Groups Most Affected

The study identifies a stark decline in trust satisfaction among Gen Z policyholders, with scores plummeting by 39 points from the prior year. Additionally, policyholders with poor or fair credit reported a 28-point decrease in trust satisfaction. These findings underline the importance for insurers to prioritize transparent and accessible communication with all customer segments.

Interaction Channels Impact Trust

Trust satisfaction varied notably based on interaction channels. Customers engaging through advisors, agents, mobile apps, and websites scored a higher trust satisfaction of 757, compared to a score of 581 among those with no direct interactions. Policyholders confident in receiving coordinated multi-channel service demonstrated trust scores 148 points higher than those less certain of such integration.

Distribution Models Influence Satisfaction

The distribution model also plays a role in customer satisfaction. Centrally distributed policies—those bought directly via call centers, websites, or third-party platforms—saw a 12-point dip in satisfaction to 684. Conversely, satisfaction with policies distributed through agents, brokers, and financial advisors rose by 6 points to 645, highlighting a preference for personal interaction despite generally higher scores for centralized distribution methods.

Provider Score
Nationwide 701
State Farm 692
Mutual of Omaha 680

Nationwide led the rankings among individual life insurance providers with a customer satisfaction score of 701. State Farm and Mutual of Omaha followed closely. The study assessed experiences across eight factors, including trust, value for price, ease of doing business, and digital channel effectiveness. According to the survey, coordinated service across various touchpoints notably enhances overall customer satisfaction, underscoring the need for insurers to integrate diverse service channels effectively.