New IBHS Mandate Impacts Fortified Roof Recertification and Insurance Rates

Asphalt roofing manufacturers are raising alarms over a new mandate from the Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS) that limits Fortified roof recertification for roofs older than 15 years.

The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) is challenging the basis of this requirement, citing issues with the nonstandard methods and limited scope of the supporting research. ARMA argues that the study fails to account for improvements in installation practices and positive performance metrics seen in recent years. This mandate, set to be enforced starting January 1, 2027, emerges from a decade-long IBHS study examining shingle performance in various testing locations and significant wind events.

Understanding the Fortified Program's Impact

The restriction pertains specifically to the Fortified certification, which is known to potentially offer policyholders reductions in insurance premiums. However, IBHS clarified that this certification age cap is not a reflection of shingle lifespan or a reason for immediate roof replacement. The Fortified program has gained significant traction, particularly in Alabama, spurred by state-supported wind mitigation efforts and building regulations. Data from May indicated that over 100,000 properties achieved Fortified status, emphasizing the program's growth and influence.

ARMA’s Advocacy and Industry Response

ARMA encourages insurers to avoid expanding this age limitation into stricter underwriting policies. They request that risk assessments for wind damage prioritize updated engineering practices, technological advancements in shingle production, and craftsmanship in installations. Similarly, Mike Silvers, technical services lead at the Florida Roofing and Sheetmetal Association, highlighted how shingle quality and craftsmanship significantly impact roof durability. He noted that more economical three-tab shingles usually have shorter lifespans compared to more resilient multilayer architectural designs.

Florida's Legislative Influence

This situation echoes past measures in Florida, where some insurers stopped covering homes with roofs over ten years old, despite warranties suggesting up to 30 years of service life. A 2022 legislative mandate countered this by barring insurers from declining policy renewals solely based on roof age under 15 years, requiring coverage continuity if inspections show substantial remaining lifespan. This legislative intervention shaped underwriting practices, with roof age continuing to be a significant factor in insurance pricing models.

Factor Implication
Roof Age Impacts insurance pricing models
Craftsmanship Affects roof longevity and durability
Shingle Quality Varies lifespans among shingle types

IBHS Findings and Future Concerns

Recent IBHS analysis unearthed disparities in asphalt shingle performance across diverse climates, highlighting potentially increased risks in certain environments. Insurance professionals in Florida face difficulties securing agreements for older roofs, even those still within manufacturer warranty periods. Florida's Insurance Commissioner, Mike Yaworsky, in 2024, questioned the use of asphalt shingles given the state's weather conditions, proposing gradual replacement—a suggestion that has faced pushback from manufacturers.