Innovative Strategies for Body Shops in Insurance Claims

Andy Grundman's unique approach to dealing with underpaid repair charges is providing a blueprint for body shops looking to recoup costs without passing them on to customers.

As the owner of Pat’s Body Shop in Wausau, Wisconsin, Grundman has turned to the small claims court to address gaps in insurance payouts. Over the past two years, this strategy has netted him over $40,000, with an additional $60,000 in pending claims. His method uses post-loss assignments, which allow him to step into the shoes of the policyholder and dispute claims directly with insurers. This approach empowers him to challenge shortfalls such as reduced labor rates and other unpaid procedures.

Shifting Strategies in Insurance Disputes

At the 2026 SEMA Show in Las Vegas, Grundman shared insights into navigating small claims court sessions effectively. By using the assignment of claim benefits, his business can take direct action against insurers while retaining the confidence of his customer base. His refusal to join direct repair programs (DRPs), which often bind repair shops to insurer terms, highlights his commitment to customer advocacy.

Grundman argues that many body shops absorb costs that insurers shortfall, potentially endangering their financial health. This sentiment has driven him to create Good Faith Payment Systems, initially founded to assist other body shops but now evolving toward consultancy and documentation support for claims. Grundman is also authoring a guide to using Wisconsin's small claims system to help other shops document claims and communicate effectively with customers.

Leveraging Wisconsin's Small Claims System

In Wisconsin, the small claims process allows for addressing civil money claims up to $10,000, with an increase to $15,000 set for 2027. Grundman emphasizes the importance of repair shops understanding and meticulously following their state’s small claims procedures. He suggests consolidating multiple claims against a single insurer whenever possible to enhance recovery outcomes.

  • Maximum Claim: Up to $10,000 (set to increase to $15,000 in 2027)
  • Key Strategy: Consolidate multiple claims for increased impact
  • Communication: Keep customers informed throughout the claims process

Building Trust Through Transparency

Involving customers in the claims process is a cornerstone of Grundman’s strategy. By maintaining transparency, body shops not only align with customer interests but also enhance their credibility with insurers. His experience demonstrates that dealing directly with insurers and involving customers can lead to more favorable negotiations.

Pat’s Body Shop operates a small yet effective team with annual revenues under $1 million. Grundman’s proactive stance on recovering repair costs reflects a broader trend within the industry. His methods present a potential model for others seeking to advocate effectively for services while maintaining client satisfaction.