Commercial Auto Insurance Losses and Market Trends in 2025



In 2025, U.S. commercial auto insurers reported an underwriting loss of $2.2 billion, representing a significant 55% improvement compared to the previous year, according to a recent AM Best report.

The commercial auto insurance sector, a consistent source of underwriting losses since 2015, managed to narrow its deficit with notable financial gains. A critical factor in this improvement was a 6% increase in net premiums written, reflecting strategic pricing and premium adjustments. Insurers navigated the complex landscape of incurred losses, keeping them relatively stable while benefiting from the lowest level of adverse reserve development seen in a decade.

Insights Into Liability and Physical Damage

The report reveals interesting dynamics between the liability and physical damage segments within commercial auto insurance. Liability continued to be a source of significant financial strain, with underwriting losses exceeding $4.6 billion in 2025. Nevertheless, this loss was a marked improvement from the $6.39 billion deficit in 2024 and $5.9 billion in 2023. The liability segment's profitability remains challenged by social inflation trends that increase pressure on claims costs. Notably, liability constitutes 77% of commercial auto’s Net Premiums Written (NPW), underscoring its critical impact on the sector’s financial health.

In contrast, the physical damage segment experienced a $2.4 billion gain in losses. Proactive measures in fleet monitoring and maintenance have resulted in reduced accident frequency, benefitting physical damage profitability, according to David Blades, AM Best’s associate director of industry research. These operational improvements have significantly contributed to the commercial auto sector’s financial progress.

Market Outlook and Pricing Dynamics

Looking ahead, the industry’s financial trajectory suggests cautious optimism. The direct loss ratio dropped to 66.1% in the first half of 2026, while the combined ratio improved to 96.6 in 2025 from 101.4 the previous year. As a result of these favorable trends, premium increases have moderated, with the second quarter of 2026 seeing the lowest rate hikes in over a decade. For insurance professionals, this shift reflects a more stabilized pricing environment, which may provide opportunities for enhanced customer retention and competitive positioning.

Year Liability Loss
(in billions)
Physical Damage Gain
(in billions)
2023 $5.9 N/A
2024 $6.39 N/A
2025 $4.6 $2.4